Screen Replacement Options for Samsung S20: A Performance Comparison

When a customer walks into your store with a shattered Samsung phone, the pressure is on to recommend the best screen replacement option. Since 2023, demand for Android screen repairs has surged, particularly for high-end models like Samsung's N and S series. To meet this demand, manufacturers now offer a variety of replacement screens, each with distinct advantages and trade-offs. This article examines three primary types of replacement screens—refurbished OEM, third-party OLED, and third-party Incell—using the Samsung S20 as a case study. Through rigorous testing, we evaluate their performance across four key metrics to help you make an informed decision.

Overview of Screen Types: Strengths and Weaknesses

Refurbished OEM Screens

These screens are harvested from original devices, retaining most components with only minor replacements (e.g., front glass or flex cables). While slight aging may be visible, rigorous refurbishing ensures near-original quality, making them ideal for users prioritizing premium performance.

Third-Party OLED Screens

Manufactured by independent factories, these OLED screens deliver impressive brightness and contrast. However, design incompatibilities may require proprietary frames for certain models.

Third-Party Incell Screens

Featuring a flat design with a thicker bottom bezel, Incell screens sacrifice display area and lack advanced features like under-display fingerprint sensors. Their modest performance suits budget-conscious users.

Performance Analysis: Four Critical Tests

1. Color Accuracy: Natural vs. Vibrant

Refurbished OEM: Natural, true-to-life colors with high precision.
Third-party OLED: Cooler, oversaturated tones that may cause eye strain.
Incell: Darker hues with reduced contrast, leading to detail loss in shadows.

2. Brightness and Color Gamut

Refurbished OEM: 394.45 nits brightness, 106.6% gamut coverage.
Third-party OLED: 364.60 nits brightness, 110.9% gamut.
Incell: 203.13 nits brightness, 70.4% gamut—unsuitable for bright environments.

3. Resolution and Pixel Arrangement

Refurbished OEM: Diamond pixel layout for superior clarity.
Third-party OLED: Proprietary TCL CSOT arrangement, slightly less sharp.
Incell: Standard RGB layout with basic clarity.

4. Touch Responsiveness

Refurbished OEM: Precise, consistent input.
Third-party OLED: Slight lag but adequate for daily use.
Incell: Noticeable latency and reduced accuracy.

Which Screen Fits Your Needs?

For premium quality: Refurbished OEM screens excel in all metrics.
For value seekers: Third-party OLED balances cost and performance.
For tight budgets: Incell screens provide basic functionality.

Conclusion

Selecting the right screen hinges on balancing performance, budget, and user preferences. By understanding the trade-offs between refurbished, third-party OLED, and Incell options, repair professionals can confidently guide customers toward the optimal choice.